Why Good Intentions Aren't Enough: A Lesson in Intent vs. Impact

A respected spiritual teacher withdrew a project after community concerns — without any accusation of wrongdoing. Here's the lesson on intent vs. impact.

A Teacher Who Stepped Back Without Being Accused

In June 2026, Sri M — a widely respected spiritual teacher and Padma Bhushan awardee — withdrew a proposed meditation retreat project in Karnataka after the local Kodava community protested, citing concerns about potential damage to land near a sacred temple. Notably, he was not accused of any bad intent. There was no scandal, no allegation of wrongdoing. He simply listened, and stepped back.

It's a quiet story, easy to scroll past. But it holds an unusually clear example of a principle that's much harder to see in the moment: someone with genuinely good intentions still adjusting course because of the impact their plans would have had on people who weren't in the room when the plans were made.

This Isn't a Story About Wrongdoing

It would be easy — and lazy — to frame this as "even respected gurus mess up." That misses the point entirely. This isn't a story about someone getting caught doing something wrong. It's a story about how good intentions, on their own, were never going to be a sufficient basis for a decision that affected a community's sacred land.

The more useful, more uncomfortable question this raises applies well beyond spiritual teachers: what happens when intentions are sincere, but insufficiently informed by the people who will actually live with the consequences?

Why Good Intentions Aren't the Whole Answer

There's a common assumption that if someone's heart is in the right place, that more or less settles the matter. Leadership research consistently pushes back on this. As one leadership framework puts it, there is often a real gap — a delta — between what a person intends and how their actions actually land on others, and that gap doesn't close itself just because the intention was good.

The core distinction

Intent is what lives inside a person's mind before they act. Impact is what actually happens to the people affected by the action. These can diverge sharply, even when intent is completely sincere — and it's impact, not intent, that the affected community actually has to live with.

This is why "was this person a good person?" and "did this decision land well?" are two separate questions, and both need to be asked. Good character does not automatically produce good outcomes for everyone involved; it has to be paired with genuine listening.

What the Gita Teaches About Listening and Humility

The Bhagavad Gita places enormous emphasis on humility (amanitva) as a foundational quality of wisdom — not as a soft virtue, but as a practical necessity for right action.

"Humility; pridelessness; nonviolence; tolerance; simplicity; approaching a bona fide spiritual master... these are declared to be knowledge, and all that is opposed to these is ignorance."

— Bhagavad Gita, Chapter 13, Verses 8–9

Humility here isn't self-deprecation. It's the willingness to hold your own judgment lightly enough to actually hear when someone tells you your good intention is landing as harm. Sri M's decision to step back is a real-world example of this principle in action — humility expressed not as a private feeling, but as a visible change in course.

Where This Shows Up in Your Own Life

Few of us will ever propose a retreat near a sacred site. But the underlying pattern — good intentions colliding with an impact we didn't anticipate — shows up constantly in ordinary life: a piece of advice given to a struggling friend that actually made them feel judged, a well-meant joke that landed as a dismissal, a parenting decision made "for their own good" that a child experienced very differently.

A question worth sitting with

Who in your life have you affected — with entirely good intentions — without actually asking whether it landed well for them? The instinct is usually to defend the intention. The more useful move, and the more difficult one, is to ask instead about the impact.

Frequently Asked Questions

What happened with Sri M's meditation retreat in Karnataka?

In June 2026, spiritual teacher Sri M withdrew a proposed meditation retreat project in Kodagu, Karnataka, after the local Kodava community raised concerns about potential impact on land near a sacred temple. He was not accused of wrongdoing; he chose to step back after listening to the community's concerns.

What's the difference between intent and impact?

Intent refers to what a person means or hopes to achieve through an action. Impact refers to the actual effect that action has on others. The two can differ significantly even when intent is sincere, which is why evaluating outcomes requires looking at both.

Does the Bhagavad Gita talk about humility and listening to others?

Yes. In Chapter 13, Krishna lists humility (amanitva) among the essential qualities of true knowledge. This quality supports the willingness to listen to feedback and adjust one's actions, rather than relying solely on the sincerity of one's own intentions.

Madan Sundar Das, Director of Evolve Pune

Written By

Madan Sundar Das

Engineer turned monk, Director of Evolve Pune™ and visiting faculty at Symbiosis & Dr. D.Y. Patil MBA schools. He teaches the Bhagavad Gita, Srimad Bhagavatam and Mahabharata to professionals, students and families across India — and would love to hear from you.

Go Deeper Than a Blog Post

Study the Gita with structure, community and expert guidance at Evolve Pune.

Explore Programs Chat on WhatsApp